Flavorful consistency with beverages important this holiday season
Gingerbread top holiday flavor choice for all age groups

When the holidays roll around, everyone has their favorite seasonal flavors.
Erin Kelly, CEO at Advanced Symbolics (askpolly.ai), New York, notes that consumers are balancing traditional with new entrants.
“American’s favorite Christmas flavor is gingerbread; it came first in every age group surveyed by askpolly.ai,” Kelly says. “There is a thirst, pardon the pun, for new flavors but consumers are reluctant to get attached to new featured flavors. This preference for something new dissipates once December rolls in; familiar flavors are part of the nostalgia of the Christmas season.”
Kelly notes this is because these flavors are short-lived and those preparing them have less practice, so consumers view the flavors as inconsistent.
As for why peppermint is not as highly regarded, Kelly explains that it is tied its year-round availability.
“Not surprisingly, flavors we associated with Christmas Day or holiday dinners like gingerbread, cranberry and eggnog are the Top 3 Christmas flavors,” she says. “Interestingly, eggnog is No. 3 but is the most talked-about flavor, possibly reflecting childhood nostalgia rather than an actual taste preference.”
Yet, Kelly says that introducing a new holiday beverage can be risky for brands and restaurants, but there are ways to mitigate those risks.
“Among the 25-34 age groups ‘consistent quality every time’ was most important while ‘new flavors’ were favored mostly by the over-65 crowd,” she explains. “askpolly’s research suggest that if you want to introduce new flavors you need to talk about the recipe, why those flavors belong together and about real ingredients with nothing artificial. That strategy will reduce the risk of a seasonal flop.”
When it comes to the type of beverage, Kelly says there isn’t a single category that consumers are most interested in, based on askpolly research.
“The overwhelming engagement for holiday-themed drinks is a direct result of their deep-rooted connection to tradition, celebration and sensory enjoyment, as well as the wide variety of flavors and formats that allow nearly everyone to find a favorite,” Kelly says. “Preferences range from mulled wine, to Christmas flavored coffees to more playful or creative choices such as ‘peppermint espresso martini with a candy cane rim and whipped cream.’”
Looking for a reprint of this article?
From high-res PDFs to custom plaques, order your copy today!





