A 'Big' Threat?

December 1, 2005
/ Print / Reprints /
/ Text Size+

A ‘Big’ Threat?
Sarah Theodore  
Nutrition watchdog groups seem irresistibly drawn to the soft drink industry, no matter what these companies do to balance healthful products and indulgent offerings. This month saw two reports that went as far as comparing soft drinks to “big tobacco,” and have industry watchers predicting more changes in the way products are marketed. The first is a Massachusetts lawsuit that has been threatened by the Center for Science in the Public Interest, the Public Health Advocacy Group and a number of other lawyers, some of whom were involved in the class action lawsuits against the tobacco industry 10 years ago.
The groups plan to seek class action status for a suit that claims that kids in school are captive audiences for marketers, and that soft drinks should be banned from schools for their contribution to obesity.
Susan Neely, president of the American Beverage Association was recently quoted on the issue as saying the suit is “trying to paint a bull’s eye on a particular product and pass it off as a meaningful solution to a complicated problem.” In response to the news, the ABA released a study that shows full-calorie soft drink consumption in schools has dropped 24 percent since 2002 while purchases of bottled water, diet soft drinks, 100 percent juice and sports drinks all have increased.
The second is a report from the Institute of Medicine, a government-chartered organization, which stated that food and beverage companies are using television ads to entice kids into eating and drinking unhealthful quantities. The institute called for food and beverage manufacturers, as well as restaurants, to change their advertising within two years, getting rid of cartoon characters in marketing and increasing advertising of healthful products… or have Congress step in and mandate the changes. While the food and advertising industries criticized the report, Advertising Age warned it could become “a watershed on the scale of the 1964 Surgeon General’s report on tobacco.”
The potential litigants in Massachusetts and the Institute of Medicine report fail to acknowledge the steps the industry already has taken, including self-imposed limits on sales in schools and marketing policies regarding children, as well as the wide range of products these companies actually offer, including bottled water, low-calorie products and fruit juice. PepsiCo, in my opinion, has done the best job of showing the industry’s ability to provide balance in drinking and snacking occasions with the Smart Spot campaign it rolled out this year.
Perhaps the new year will bring with it more solutions and less fingerpointing, but I wouldn’t bet on it. Like it or not — whether it’s fair or not — it seems certain there is a big battle ahead. BI
Sneak Peek
Beverage bottler of the year — Pepsi-Cola Bottling of New York
Beverage R&D — 2006 R&D survey
Category Focus — Juices & juice drinks
Packaging — Closure technology
Corporate profile — Heineken USA
Special report — Health & wellness trends
Beverage R&D — Flavor survey
Category Focus — Ready-to-drink coffee & tea

 Did you enjoy this article? Click here to subscribe to Beverage Industry.  

You must login or register in order to post a comment.



Image Galleries

Dinner with Tequila Don Julio

Diageo is taking its Tequila Don Julio brand on the road this summer with a rolling Airstream Speakeasy mobile craft cocktail bar. The team stopped in Chicago on July 29 to share some specialty tequila cocktails paired with food from Chicago restaurants Honey Butter Fried Chicken and The Radler as well as dessert venues Black Dog Gelato and Baker Miller. (Photos by Jennifer Haderspeck)

2/18/15 2:00 pm EST

A Healthy Future: Analyzing the latest health and wellness trends in the beverage market

The beverage marketplace continues to evolve to meet new trends and regulations. Our expert speakers will share with you their insight on what health and wellness topics will be paramount for the future success in the beverage industry.


Gert van Manen, president of iTi Tropicals Inc., shares his insights on the U.S. coconut water market. Citing research from Krueger Food Laboratories, he also supplies information highlighting the difference between products that declare their added sugars and those that do not.

Beverage Industry Magazine

BI January 2015 cover

2015 January

The January 2015 Beverage Industry includes a cover story on our bottler of the year, Pepsi-Cola Bottling Co. of Luverne, as well as articles about juice drinks, the 2015 New Product Development Outlook, and more. Check it out today!

Table Of Contents Subscribe


What anticipated top-selling flavor do you think will be the most successful in 2015?
View Results Poll Archive


Cleaning-in-Place: Dairy, Food and Beverage Operations, 3rd Edition

This book addresses the principles of cleaning operations, water supply issues and the science of detergents and disinfectants.

More Products

Beverage Insider eNewsletter

Are you an Insider? Subscribe to Beverage Industry’s weekly e-newsletter to receive news headlines, new product information and magazine highlights.   


facebook40 twitter    youtubelinkedgoogle+ icon 40px


Beverage Industry Webinars are an easy, effective and convenient way to get educated and informed on the latest industry trends and topics. All Webinars are FREE unless indicated. For more information, check out our Events page!